I'm not a doctor or a dietitian. I'm a 35-year-old desk worker who took zero supplements his whole life, then started boxing and got humbled. Now I'm trying things one at a time, on myself, and writing down what actually happens. This is my log, not advice.
experimentCreatineMultivitamin
Day 5 — the pump is real, but so are the rumors
Push-ups and squats felt different today. The pump is definitely there. But I also read some things about creatine that made me pause.
What I ate today.
- **Breakfast:** oatmeal and coffee. First time eating breakfast in a while.
- **Lunch:** a hamburger. Not a clean choice, but it is what it is.
- **Dinner:** **beef tenderloin** with plain white rice. Good protein, at least.
What I took.
Same stack — **creatine 5 g** and one **multivitamin** with a meal. Day 5, no changes.
What happened at the gym.
Boxing first, three rounds. Nothing dramatic to report there — still getting through them.
Then push-ups and squats. And this is where it got interesting.
The pump — I'm calling it real now.
I've been careful about this for four days, trying not to imagine things. But today, during push-ups and squats, the pump was unmistakable. My chest and legs felt **tighter, fuller, and the swell lasted longer** after the set ended. It wasn't subtle. It wasn't "maybe." It was there.
Possible explanations:
- Creatine increases intramuscular water and phosphocreatine, which directly feeds pump and between-set recovery.
- I ate more carbs today (oatmeal, rice, burger bun) so glycogen might be fuller.
- I'm just paying more attention because I'm looking for it.
Even if it's a mix, the sensation was strong enough that I'm no longer doubting whether something is happening. Something is.
The downside — the rumors got to me.
I read some recent posts and articles suggesting creatine might be linked to **hair loss** and **kidney stress**. I don't know how solid the evidence is, and I know a lot of supplement scare stories are overblown. But I also know I'm not an expert, and I can't just dismiss it because I like the pump.
My plan: run the full month, keep logging everything, and then decide whether to continue based on how I feel and what I observe. If I notice anything off — hair shedding, weird fatigue, anything — I'll stop immediately. If not, I'll reassess at 30 days.
The weight goal — still stuck at 80 kg.
I'm still **187 cm, 80 kg**. Goal is 85 kg. The honest truth is that eating enough is harder for me than the workouts. I can box and lift, but forcing down the calories to actually gain weight is a struggle I haven't solved yet. Today's oatmeal at breakfast was a small step, but I know I need more consistent surplus if I want the scale to move.
Overall condition.
**Better than baseline.** The pump is the standout. No stomach issues. Sleep was fine. No hair or kidney symptoms I can detect, but it's only day 5 — too early to call anything on that front.
One month, then I decide.
Currently in my stack
What I'm actually taking
These are the two products in my live Journal experiment. Product information is quoted from each product's iHerb page.
Nutricost
Nutricost Performance Creatine Monohydrate
Form Powder
Serving 1 Scoop (5 g)
Servings 60
Supplement facts
Ingredient
Amount
%DV
Creatine monohydrate (micronized)
5 g
—
Other ingredients: None.
Suggested use. Loading: Days 1–5, mix 1 scoop in 6–10 oz water and take 4 times daily; Maintenance: from Day 6 onward, take 1 scoop once daily.
Warnings. For healthy adults 18 years or older. Consult a healthcare professional before use if pregnant or nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition. Keep out of reach of children. Do not use if safety seal is broken or missing.
Other ingredients: Hypromellose (cellulose capsule), microcrystalline cellulose, stearic acid (vegetable source) and silicon dioxide. Vitamin E from non-GMO soy. Not manufactured with wheat, gluten, milk, egg, fish or shellfish ingredients.
Suggested use. Take 1 capsule daily with a meal.
Warnings. For adults only. Consult physician if pregnant/nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition. Keep out of reach of children. This product contains Biotin which may interfere with some blood test results.
Personal experience, not medical advice. I'm not a clinician — this is what I do, not what you should do. Talk to a professional before changing your own stack.Read the full disclaimer →